Gardiner Expressway

Toronto, Ontario

Built between 1955 and 1966 by the Ministry of Transportation of Toronto (MTO), Toronto's Frederick G. Gardiner Expressway is a major east-west thoroughfare that connects downtown Toronto to its western suburbs. At the time it was built, most of the area was industrial and not a civic waterfront destination. However, its path still cut through large amounts of beloved park land, including the complete removal of the frequented Sunnyside Amusement Park.

The Gardiner Expressway also required the re-routing of the existing tree-lined Lake Shore Boulevard and putting it in the shadow of the new elevated eight lane expressway, separating the city from its Lake Ontario waterfront. What was originally built to accommodate much less daily traffic, the Gardiner, east of Jarvis Street, now carries 120,000 vehicles daily and costs around $10 million annually in repairs.

Toronto Frederick Gardiner Expressway
Lake Shore Boulevard is crowded out by new expressway, 1963. Source: Get Toronto Moving

For years, citizens of Toronto have called for the removal of the elevated expressway as it runs from downtown eastward. And they've had some success: a far eastern portion of the freeway was successfully removed in 1999. It was originally intended to connect downtown to the suburb of Scarborough, but a citizens' revolt stopped the freeway's progress and left only a 1.3 km stub. The result was a beautiful linear park that includes bikeways and public art installations. However, much of the eastern portion remains.

Toronto Frederick Gardiner Expressway options, boulevard
Options for future of Gardiner Expressway. Source: News Talk 1010

Just recently, the City of Toronto and WATERFRONToronto finished work on the Gardiner Expressway & Lake Shore Boulevard Reconfiguration Environmental Assessment & Urban Design Study, which will help determine the future of the 2.4 km elevated section of the expressway from Jarvis Street to just east of the Dan Valley Parkway abutting Lake Ontario. Four main approaches are being considered for the Gardiner: maintaining ($235m), removing ($240m-$360m), improving ($420m-$630m), or replacing ($610m-$910m). In contrast, the Toronto City Council already approved a budget – between 2013 and 2022 – for a nearly $500 million rehabilitation of the downtown expressway. Interestingly, the maintenance work will move west to east down the freeway – perhaps in anticipation of the removal campaign's success.

Former Toronto Mayor David Miller believes tearing down the Gardiner to be "the most practical approach and offers the greatest public benefits."  In June of 2015, the City Council voted 24–21 in favour of the "hybrid" option, 26–19 against the "remove" option, and 44–1 against the "maintain" option. Reconstruction of the Jarvis to DVP section and the removal of the section east of the DVP was not expected to start before 2019. In January of 2016, city and Waterfront Toronto staff released three hybrid configurations-- but ultimately ended up endorsing the so-called Hybrid 3 option, which removes the Logan Ave. on- and off-ramps and adds two ramps in the Keating precinct.

The 2015-206 council-approved budget for Toronto has since allocated about $900 million be allocated for roadway repairs over the next decade. Rehabilitation activities on the Gardiner Expressway will consist of the following:

  • Visual inspections and controlled chipping
  • Ground penetrating radar (GPR) and detailed condition survey
  • Bent repairs and temporary bracing
  • York Street to Jarvis Street rehabilitation contract
  • Jarvis Street to Don Roadway interim repairs
  • Deck replacement at Strachan Avenue
  • Falling concrete incidents

Additionally, Toronto’s public works committee has recently recommended that the Toronto council support a plan to push the eastern section of the Gardiner Expressway farther north, despite a $1.052-billion price tag that’s double the teardown option council rejected.

Syracuse I-81
Gardiner Expressway as it stands today. Source: ArchDaily

Be sure to check out Gardiner East Reconfiguration Environmental Assessment & Urban Design Study website and the Waterfront website for ways to help turn this expressway into a boulevard.

Keep up with their Existing Condition page.

Top image source: Vik Pahwa

Similar Projects

I-81 transformation into a boulevard

Syracuse, New York

The construction of Interstate 81 in Syracuse came with the forced displacement of nearly 1,300 residents from the city's 15th Ward.

Harbor Drive removal

Portland, Oregon

In the history of American freeway teardowns, Portland's Harbor Drive holds an auspicious position. It stands as the first major highway to be intentionally removed.

McGrath Highway

Somerville, Massachusetts

Since 1928, the McGrath Highway - between the Charles and Mystic Rivers in Boston - has increased motorists’ travel speed, to the detriment of all other modes.